New York has a gift shop on nearly every corner, but only a handful feel worth lugging an extra tote around for. Skip the generic “I ❤️ NY” kiosk and head for these spots instead. Each one packs local character, wallet-friendly finds, and a story you’ll want to tell when someone asks, “Where’d you get that?”
1. Grand Slam New York – Times Square
Right in the glare of the billboards, this three-level store is souvenir overload in the best way: tees, magnets, Yankees caps, mini Statues of Liberty—everything. Why pop in: biggest selection and steady sales racks. Quick tip: bundle tees and magnets for a cheaper per-item price. Where: 1557 Broadway, Midtown
2. New York Transit Museum Store – Grand Central
Vintage subway tokens, map-printed socks, and even train-car Lego sets. Pure gold for subway nerds. Why pop in: items you literally can’t find elsewhere. Quick tip: grab the classic Vignelli subway map poster—ships easily in a tube. Where: 89 E 42nd St (inside Grand Central)
3. FDNY Fire Zone – Rockefeller Center
Part mini-museum, part store. Pick up firefighter patches, kid-size helmets, or charity tees that support New York’s Bravest. Why pop in: proceeds help fund FDNY safety programs. Quick tip: time your visit for a free fire-safety demo with the kids. Where: 61 W 48th St
4. Strand Bookstore – Union Square
Eighteen miles of books plus killer merch: tote bags, enamel pins, and notebooks stamped with the Strand logo. Why pop in: the tote is a badge of honor for book lovers. Quick tip: check the Rare Book Room upstairs for vintage NY postcards. Where: 828 Broadway
5. MoMA Design Store – Midtown
Museum-curated gifts—think sleek coffee mugs, Bauhaus puzzles, and kid toys that belong on a gallery wall. Why pop in: every item screams good design. Quick tip: ask for tax-free form if you’re an out-of-state visitor spending $110+. Where: 44 W 53rd St
6. NY Gift Shop – Little Italy
Old-school vibe with snow globes, espresso-cup sets, and “Nonna Loves NYC” aprons. Why pop in: mash-up of Italian pride and NYC classics. Quick tip: pair your shopping with a cannoli on Mulberry Street. Where: 106 Mulberry St
7. Brooklyn Flea – DUMBO & Williamsburg
Rotating open-air market stacked with vinyl, up-cycled jewelry, and retro Knicks gear. Why pop in: true one-offs you’ll never see again. Quick tip: arrive when gates open; the best vintage disappears by noon. Where: 80 Pearl St (check schedule)
8. Economy Candy – Lower East Side
Since 1937. Walls of bulk bins, old-timey sweets, and NYC-themed chocolate bars that travel well. Why pop in: cheap, cheerful gifts that won’t shatter in a suitcase. Quick tip: snag their pre-packed “NYC Mix” for grab-and-go gifts. Where: 108 Rivington St
9. Artists & Fleas – Chelsea Market
Indoor bazaar of local makers: screen-printed tees, urban photography prints, handmade perfume. Why pop in: chat directly with the artist, not a cashier. Quick tip: look for limited-run NYC skyline prints—easy to frame later. Where: 88 10th Ave
10. Union Square Holiday Market – Seasonal
Open November–December. Wooden stalls selling ornaments, mini-bagel candles, and knitted “I ❤️ NY” beanies. Why pop in: festive atmosphere plus local cider to warm your hands. Quick tip: weekdays are calmer and merch is restocked by noon. Where: E 14th St & Broadway
Fast FAQ
Where can I grab a cheap magnet? Times Square street vendors under the big screens.
Need something truly unique? Hit Brooklyn Flea or Artists & Fleas for small-batch goods.
Flying carry-on only? Flat items like posters from the Transit Museum and Strand tote bags pack easiest.
Final Tip
Set aside one afternoon, pick three shops on this list near each other, and wander. You’ll end up with a keepsake that feels earned—and a story to match.
0 Comments